Library & files

Lossy compression

Lossy compression shrinks a file by discarding audio a listener is unlikely to notice. What it removes is gone permanently, and encoding an already-lossy file removes more on top.

Measured in real DJ libraries

83.3% of the files in a real DJ library are lossy — whatever the forum argument says, it is settled in practice.

The rule that matters is not “never use lossy”, it is never to encode FROM a lossy source. Every re-encode throws away more and none of it comes back, so keep one lossless master per record and generate the club copy from that rather than from another MP3.

83.3%

Of a real library

81.9%

MP3 alone

1.4%

AAC / M4A

16.7%

Lossless, for contrast

Updated daily from Rekordbox collections DJs have imported to Mixgraph. Method: what lossless actually guarantees.

Why it matters

The word "compression" is doing two unrelated jobs and it causes real confusion. Dynamic-range compression is an effect that changes how a track sounds; data compression is a storage decision that ideally changes nothing. A track can be heavily compressed in one sense and not the other.

The rule that actually costs DJs music is the second encode. Converting a 320 kbps MP3 to another lossy format — for a stick, for a player, for a share — runs the discarding step again on material that has already been thinned, and the result is worse than either step alone suggests.

Frequently asked

What does lossy mean?+

That the encoder discarded part of the audio to make the file smaller, choosing material a listener is least likely to miss. The discarded part cannot be recovered by decoding.

Is converting MP3 to MP3 bad?+

Yes, if it is a re-encode. Every lossy encode runs the discarding step again on material that has already been thinned. Copying the file is free; converting it is not.

Is lossy compression the same as a compressor?+

No. A compressor is an audio effect that reduces dynamic range. Lossy compression is a storage technique that reduces file size. The shared word is a coincidence of English.

Related terms