Library & files

Lossy compression

Lossy compression shrinks a file by discarding audio a listener is unlikely to notice. What it removes is gone permanently, and encoding an already-lossy file removes more on top.

In practice

Every re-encode removes more, and none of it comes back — keep one lossless master and generate the rest from it.

If all you have is a lossy file, copy it rather than converting it: moving an MP3 to a stick as an MP3 costs nothing, converting it to AAC costs a generation. Where you have no choice, go up in bit rate rather than down, which does not recover anything but stops the second encoder throwing away more than it has to. And treat a file you cannot account for the history of as suspect on a big system.

Permanent

What the discarding is

Every encode

When it happens again

Copy, do not convert

The rule that saves you

Where these come from: Codec behaviour and library practice, not catalog figures. For what we can measure, see the master to generate from.

Why it matters

The word "compression" is doing two unrelated jobs and it causes real confusion. Dynamic-range compression is an effect that changes how a track sounds; data compression is a storage decision that ideally changes nothing. A track can be heavily compressed in one sense and not the other.

The rule that actually costs DJs music is the second encode. Converting a 320 kbps MP3 to another lossy format — for a stick, for a player, for a share — runs the discarding step again on material that has already been thinned, and the result is worse than either step alone suggests.

Frequently asked

What does lossy mean?+

That the encoder discarded part of the audio to make the file smaller, choosing material a listener is least likely to miss. The discarded part cannot be recovered by decoding.

Is converting MP3 to MP3 bad?+

Yes, if it is a re-encode. Every lossy encode runs the discarding step again on material that has already been thinned. Copying the file is free; converting it is not.

Is lossy compression the same as a compressor?+

No. A compressor is an audio effect that reduces dynamic range. Lossy compression is a storage technique that reduces file size. The shared word is a coincidence of English.

Related terms